Dissenting Opinions: Football Rankings - 2024 Draft

Ed Birdsall (Talking Points Sports) vs Expert Consensus (All Experts)

STD PPR HALF

Ed Birdsall likes him more

change

Rank Player ECR Diff.
22 Rachaad White TB - RB 35 +13
24 Cooper Kupp LAR - WR 39 +15
48 Tank Dell HOU - WR 60 +12
49 Mark Andrews BAL - TE 61 +12
70 Justin Herbert LAC - QB 93 +23
75 Jaxon Smith-Njigba SEA - WR 88 +13
76 Nick Chubb CLE - RB 96 +20
82 Caleb Williams CHI - QB 95 +13
85 Jake Ferguson DAL - TE 99 +14
87 Ladd McConkey LAC - WR 115 +28
97 Brock Bowers LV - TE 109 +12
101 Jonathon Brooks CAR - RB 142 +41
109 Keon Coleman BUF - WR 125 +16
133 Will Levis TEN - QB 147 +14
135 Adonai Mitchell IND - WR 167 +32
137 Cade Otton TB - TE 154 +17
140 Rico Dowdle DAL - RB 157 +17
146 J.J. McCarthy MIN - QB 172 +26
153 Ricky Pearsall SF - WR 209 +56
154 Tucker Kraft GB - TE 171 +17
156 AJ Dillon GB - RB 187 +31
157 Taysom Hill NO - TE 227 +70
161 MarShawn Lloyd GB - RB 183 +22
167 Troy Franklin DEN - WR 196 +29
181 Kenneth Gainwell PHI - RB 206 +25
193 Minnesota Vikings MIN - DST 216 +23
195 Michael Mayer LV - TE 215 +20
199 Ka'imi Fairbairn HOU - K 217 +18
200 Ray Davis BUF - RB 224 +24
202 Isaiah Likely BAL - TE 221 +19
203 Jermaine Burton CIN - WR 226 +23
204 Jonathan Mingo CAR - WR 220 +16
205 Houston Texans HOU - DST 225 +20
216 Dustin Hopkins CLE - K 239 +23
218 Jamaal Williams NO - RB 233 +15
219 Denver Broncos DEN - DST 252 +33
223 Odell Beckham Jr. MIA - WR 254 +31
226 Alec Pierce IND - WR 255 +29
228 Tyler Higbee LAR - TE 250 +22
229 DJ Chark Jr. LAC - WR 266 +37
230 Justice Hill BAL - RB 247 +17
231 Devontez Walker BAL - WR 258 +27
234 Cincinnati Bengals CIN - DST 281 +47
237 Jeff Wilson Jr. MIA - RB 278 +41
240 K.J. Osborn NE - WR 257 +17
242 Kimani Vidal LAC - RB 265 +23
246 Kadarius Toney KC - WR 287 +41
248 New England Patriots NE - DST 295 +47
252 Daniel Carlson LV - K 276 +24
256 Tyrone Tracy Jr. NYG - RB 280 +24
261 Andrei Iosivas CIN - WR 274 +13
264 Jacob Cowing SF - WR 283 +19
265 Kareem Hunt FA - RB 290 +25
266 DeVante Parker PHI - WR 286 +20
267 Theo Johnson NYG - TE 319 +52
274 Deuce Vaughn DAL - RB 288 +14
277 Emari Demercado ARI - RB 306 +29
282 Pierre Strong Jr. CLE - RB 299 +17
287 Tyler Scott CHI - WR 302 +15
288 Robert Woods HOU - WR 301 +13
294 Hunter Renfrow FA - WR 324 +30
297 Marquez Valdes-Scantling BUF - WR 332 +35
300 Joshua Kelley FA - RB 317 +17
314 Matt Breida FA - RB 326 +12
315 Latavius Murray FA - RB 338 +23
316 Salvon Ahmed MIA - RB 329 +13
319 Brandon Powell MIN - WR 425 +106
321 Keaontay Ingram KC - RB 343 +22
322 Kenny Pickett PHI - QB 344 +22
325 Kenny McIntosh SEA - RB 413 +88
326 Chris Brooks MIA - RB 450 +124
327 Kyle Philips TEN - WR 431 +104
328 Quez Watkins PIT - WR 445 +117
329 Ryan Tannehill FA - QB 457 +128
330 Tim Patrick DEN - WR 397 +67
331 Austin Hooper NE - TE 386 +55
332 Trayveon Williams CIN - RB 443 +111
333 Frank Gore Jr. BUF - RB 437 +104
334 Ty Johnson BUF - RB 432 +98
335 Jake Browning CIN - QB 420 +85
336 David Bell CLE - WR 436 +100
337 Isaiah McKenzie NYG - WR 439 +102
338 Erick All Jr. CIN - TE 358 +20
339 Jamison Crowder WAS - WR 451 +112
340 Chase Claypool BUF - WR 417 +77
341 Harrison Bryant LV - TE 456 +115
342 Johnny Mundt MIN - TE 408 +66
344 Jared Wiley KC - TE 448 +104
345 Foster Moreau NO - TE 440 +95
346 Xavier Gipson NYJ - WR 435 +89
347 Patrick Taylor Jr. SF - RB 438 +91
348 Braxton Berrios MIA - WR 447 +99
349 Chris Moore ARI - WR 434 +85
350 Leonard Fournette FA - RB 416 +66
351 DeeJay Dallas ARI - RB 419 +68
352 Cade Stover HOU - TE 376 +24
353 Boston Scott LAR - RB 429 +76
354 Jameis Winston CLE - QB 410 +56
355 Mac Jones JAC - QB 423 +68
357 Jawhar Jordan HOU - RB 415 +58
358 Parris Campbell PHI - WR 409 +51
359 Terrace Marshall Jr. CAR - WR 404 +45
360 Justyn Ross KC - WR 421 +61
361 Kevin Harris NE - RB 424 +63
362 Josh Oliver MIN - TE 406 +44
363 Sean Tucker TB - RB 392 +29
364 Darnell Washington PIT - TE 403 +39
365 Tyquan Thornton NE - WR 426 +61
366 Cedrick Wilson Jr. NO - WR 442 +76
367 Drew Lock NYG - QB 383 +16
368 Durham Smythe MIA - TE 427 +59
369 Jase McClellan ATL - RB 433 +64
371 Jarrett Stidham DEN - QB 390 +19
372 Nick Westbrook-Ikhine TEN - WR 388 +16
373 Mecole Hardman Jr. FA - WR 407 +34
374 Charlie Jones CIN - WR 422 +48
375 Nick Folk TEN - K 411 +36
376 Jamari Thrash CLE - WR 401 +25
378 Isaiah Hodgins NYG - WR 402 +24
393 Irv Smith Jr. KC - TE 405 +12
394 Will Mallory IND - TE 428 +34
401 Cole Turner WAS - TE 430 +29
418 Kendall Milton PHI - RB 458 +40

Expert Consensus likes him more

change

Rank Player Expert Diff.
45 Alvin Kamara NO - RB 64 +19
49 Christian Kirk JAC - WR 61 +12
74 Evan Engram JAC - TE 94 +20
76 Jayden Reed GB - WR 89 +13
82 Hollywood Brown KC - WR 95 +13
89 David Njoku CLE - TE 105 +16
98 Raheem Mostert MIA - RB 117 +19
105 Tyler Lockett SEA - WR 120 +15
107 Devin Singletary NYG - RB 121 +14
131 Chuba Hubbard CAR - RB 145 +14
132 Antonio Gibson NE - RB 147 +15
134 Curtis Samuel BUF - WR 164 +30
136 Brandin Cooks DAL - WR 149 +13
146 Joshua Palmer LAC - WR 177 +31
148 Rashid Shaheed NO - WR 169 +21
149 Roschon Johnson CHI - RB 174 +25
151 Kendre Miller NO - RB 163 +12
152 Khalil Shakir BUF - WR 165 +13
156 Hunter Henry NE - TE 225 +69
159 Juwan Johnson NO - TE 172 +13
160 Quentin Johnston LAC - WR 183 +23
161 Chigoziem Okonkwo TEN - TE 180 +19
164 DeMario Douglas NE - WR 179 +15
166 Wan'Dale Robinson NYG - WR 201 +35
168 Michael Wilson ARI - WR 194 +26
179 Rashod Bateman BAL - WR 196 +17
181 Dontayvion Wicks GB - WR 198 +17
184 Darnell Mooney ATL - WR 207 +23
193 Bryce Young CAR - QB 241 +48
194 Jaylen Wright MIA - RB 227 +33
197 Elijah Mitchell SF - RB 215 +18
200 Dameon Pierce HOU - RB 221 +21
201 Ja'Lynn Polk NE - WR 222 +21
205 Alexander Mattison LV - RB 232 +27
207 Tyler Conklin NYJ - TE 235 +28
208 Roman Wilson PIT - WR 243 +35
212 Noah Fant SEA - TE 253 +41
228 Demarcus Robinson LAR - WR 244 +16
229 Ja'Tavion Sanders CAR - TE 245 +16
230 Zay Jones ARI - WR 380 +150
231 Kendrick Bourne NE - WR 257 +26
234 Bucky Irving TB - RB 262 +28
235 Tyler Boyd FA - WR 272 +37
236 Malachi Corley NYJ - WR 285 +49
237 Justin Fields PIT - QB 254 +17
238 Gerald Everett CHI - TE 255 +17
241 Javon Baker NE - WR 318 +77
244 Braelon Allen NYJ - RB 259 +15
245 Darren Waller NYG - TE 258 +13
248 Audric Estime DEN - RB 270 +22
251 Mike Gesicki CIN - TE 320 +69
259 Indianapolis Colts IND - DST 278 +19
260 Jalen McMillan TB - WR 276 +16
261 Bo Nix DEN - QB 299 +38
263 Jacksonville Jaguars JAC - DST 279 +16
267 Will Shipley PHI - RB 289 +22
268 Cedric Tillman CLE - WR 290 +22
277 Brenden Rice LAC - WR 292 +15
282 Michael Carter ARI - RB 301 +19
284 Jerick McKinnon FA - RB 298 +14
289 Israel Abanikanda NYJ - RB 302 +13
294 Detroit Lions DET - DST 317 +23
297 Greg Dulcich DEN - TE 324 +27
298 Jonnu Smith MIA - TE 441 +143
304 Zach Ertz WAS - TE 442 +138
307 Isaac Guerendo SF - RB 356 +49
309 Sam Darnold MIN - QB 443 +134
320 Luke McCaffrey WAS - WR 343 +23
321 Las Vegas Raiders LV - DST 421 +100
323 Green Bay Packers GB - DST 438 +115
325 Logan Thomas FA - TE 382 +57
327 Wil Lutz DEN - K 436 +109
330 Jacoby Brissett NE - QB 437 +107
331 Tutu Atwell LAR - WR 435 +104
333 Brandon McManus WAS - K 440 +107
334 John Metchie III HOU - WR 434 +100
335 Daniel Bellinger NYG - TE 425 +90
336 Allen Lazard NYJ - WR 431 +95
337 JuJu Smith-Schuster NE - WR 433 +96
339 Colby Parkinson LAR - TE 420 +81
340 Greg Dortch ARI - WR 432 +92
341 Malik Washington MIA - WR 429 +88
342 Donald Parham Jr. LAC - TE 430 +88
345 Tampa Bay Buccaneers TB - DST 426 +81
346 Sam Howell SEA - QB 416 +70
347 Skyy Moore KC - WR 427 +80
348 Los Angeles Rams LAR - DST 405 +57
350 Carolina Panthers CAR - DST 423 +73
351 Donovan Peoples-Jones DET - WR 424 +73
352 Rasheen Ali BAL - RB 422 +70
353 Tanner Hudson CIN - TE 410 +57
354 Royce Freeman DAL - RB 411 +57
355 Chris Boswell PIT - K 412 +57
356 Hayden Hurst LAC - TE 381 +25
357 Jalen Tolbert DAL - WR 383 +26
359 Greg Joseph GB - K 428 +69
360 Kylen Granson IND - TE 398 +38
361 Tre Tucker LV - WR 415 +54
362 Craig Reynolds DET - RB 439 +77
363 Nelson Agholor BAL - WR 414 +51
364 Jeremy Ruckert NYJ - TE 392 +28
365 Graham Gano NYG - K 413 +48
366 Bo Melton GB - WR 406 +40
367 Chase McLaughlin TB - K 400 +33
368 Seattle Seahawks SEA - DST 402 +34
370 Noah Gray KC - TE 396 +26
371 Jauan Jennings SF - WR 388 +17
372 Atlanta Falcons ATL - DST 419 +47
373 Washington Commanders WAS - DST 417 +44
375 Los Angeles Chargers LAC - DST 408 +33
377 Xavier Hutchinson HOU - WR 395 +18
380 Johnny Wilson PHI - WR 403 +23
385 Kalif Raymond DET - WR 404 +19
389 Riley Patterson JAC - K 407 +18
396 Van Jefferson PIT - WR 409 +13