Skip to main content

Dissenting Opinions: Football Rankings - 2024 Draft

Ed Birdsall (Talking Points Sports) vs Composite ADP (All Experts)

Ed Birdsall likes him more


Rank Player ADP Diff.
11 Brandon Aiyuk SF - WR 34 +23
13 Derrick Henry BAL - RB 32 +19
20 Mike Evans TB - WR 36 +16
27 Trey McBride ARI - TE 46 +19
28 DK Metcalf SEA - WR 42 +14
35 Tank Dell HOU - WR 64 +29
38 Amari Cooper CLE - WR 51 +13
41 Tee Higgins CIN - WR 58 +17
53 David Montgomery DET - RB 67 +14
55 James Conner ARI - RB 69 +14
59 Calvin Ridley TEN - WR 73 +14
67 Nick Chubb CLE - RB 94 +27
68 Gus Edwards LAC - RB 119 +51
69 Tony Pollard TEN - RB 81 +12
70 Justin Herbert LAC - QB 92 +22
82 Caleb Williams CHI - QB 98 +16
87 Christian Watson GB - WR 101 +14
88 Brian Robinson Jr. WAS - RB 104 +16
100 Dallas Goedert PHI - TE 113 +13
110 Taysom Hill NO - TE 166 +56
117 Zach Charbonnet SEA - RB 134 +17
120 Gabe Davis JAC - WR 138 +18
128 Geno Smith SEA - QB 141 +13
134 Adonai Mitchell IND - WR 153 +19
140 Rico Dowdle DAL - RB 161 +21
141 Ricky Pearsall SF - WR 178 +37
142 Ty Chandler MIN - RB 155 +13
143 Tyler Allgeier ATL - RB 159 +16
144 Khalil Herbert CHI - RB 179 +35
145 Cade Otton TB - TE 177 +32
146 J.J. McCarthy MIN - QB 158 +12
150 Baltimore Ravens BAL - DST 204 +54
153 AJ Dillon GB - RB 192 +39
154 Juwan Johnson NO - TE 187 +33
157 Tucker Kraft GB - TE 226 +69
158 Daniel Jones NYG - QB 173 +15
160 San Francisco 49ers SF - DST 211 +51
161 Keaton Mitchell BAL - RB 185 +24
166 Cleveland Browns CLE - DST 223 +57
167 Miles Sanders CAR - RB 207 +40
169 Marvin Mims Jr. DEN - WR 184 +15
170 Dallas Cowboys DAL - DST 210 +40
171 New York Jets NYJ - DST 215 +44
173 Elijah Moore CLE - WR 250 +77
179 Elijah Mitchell SF - RB 197 +18
182 Miami Dolphins MIA - DST 231 +49
183 DeMario Douglas NE - WR 200 +17
184 Kansas City Chiefs KC - DST 227 +43
185 Buffalo Bills BUF - DST 228 +43
187 Pittsburgh Steelers PIT - DST 225 +38
189 Philadelphia Eagles PHI - DST 238 +49
190 New Orleans Saints NO - DST 249 +59
193 Minnesota Vikings MIN - DST 262 +69
201 Jermaine Burton CIN - WR 217 +16
204 Kenneth Gainwell PHI - RB 216 +12
205 Houston Texans HOU - DST 235 +30
207 Jalin Hyatt NYG - WR 241 +34
211 Chicago Bears CHI - DST 239 +28
215 Dameon Pierce HOU - RB 236 +21
218 Jamaal Williams NO - RB 237 +19
219 Denver Broncos DEN - DST 277 +58
220 Darius Slayton NYG - WR 256 +36
221 Jonathan Mingo CAR - WR 272 +51
222 Treylon Burks TEN - WR 266 +44
223 Alec Pierce IND - WR 263 +40
226 DJ Chark Jr. LAC - WR 265 +39
228 Justice Hill BAL - RB 296 +68
231 Odell Beckham Jr. MIA - WR 261 +30
234 Cincinnati Bengals CIN - DST 283 +49
236 Tyler Higbee LAR - TE 264 +28
243 Rondale Moore ATL - WR 268 +25
244 A.T. Perry NO - WR 257 +13
266 Andrei Iosivas CIN - WR 294 +28
268 Trey Palmer TB - WR 288 +20
269 Josh Reynolds DEN - WR 293 +24
287 Evan Hull IND - RB 304 +17

Composite ADP likes him more


Rank Player Expert Diff.
17 Davante Adams LV - WR 30 +13
19 De'Von Achane MIA - RB 45 +26
23 Josh Jacobs GB - RB 39 +16
24 Michael Pittman Jr. IND - WR 47 +23
28 Stefon Diggs HOU - WR 50 +22
31 Travis Kelce KC - TE 49 +18
49 Alvin Kamara NO - RB 79 +30
50 Keenan Allen CHI - WR 62 +12
55 Jordan Love GB - QB 72 +17
59 Dalton Kincaid BUF - TE 76 +17
68 Kyle Pitts ATL - TE 85 +17
76 Javonte Williams DEN - RB 95 +19
77 Evan Engram JAC - TE 105 +28
78 Austin Ekeler WAS - RB 97 +19
87 Zack Moss CIN - RB 116 +29
89 Diontae Johnson CAR - WR 108 +19
105 Devin Singletary NYG - RB 119 +14
106 Trey Benson ARI - RB 129 +23
112 Brian Thomas Jr. JAC - WR 131 +19
118 Blake Corum LAR - RB 132 +14
120 Jakobi Meyers LV - WR 136 +16
128 Curtis Samuel BUF - WR 165 +37
133 Khalil Shakir BUF - WR 164 +31
137 Jaylen Wright MIA - RB 227 +90
144 Luke Musgrave GB - TE 174 +30
145 Kendre Miller NO - RB 162 +17
146 MarShawn Lloyd GB - RB 159 +13
148 Adam Thielen CAR - WR 175 +27
149 Michael Wilson ARI - WR 198 +49
151 Joshua Palmer LAC - WR 177 +26
157 Quentin Johnston LAC - WR 194 +37
160 Kimani Vidal LAC - RB 245 +85
163 Justin Fields PIT - QB 254 +91
165 Braelon Allen NYJ - RB 237 +72
167 Hunter Henry NE - TE 209 +42
170 Chigoziem Okonkwo TEN - TE 202 +32
171 Drake Maye NE - QB 213 +42
172 Dontayvion Wicks GB - WR 196 +24
174 Bryce Young CAR - QB 241 +67
175 Bucky Irving TB - RB 257 +82
176 Darnell Mooney ATL - WR 203 +27
180 Roman Wilson PIT - WR 261 +81
186 Tyler Conklin NYJ - TE 232 +46
188 Audric Estime DEN - RB 259 +71
189 Jonnu Smith MIA - TE 394 +205
191 Bo Nix DEN - QB 307 +116
193 Tyrone Tracy Jr. NYG - RB 250 +57
194 Darren Waller NYG - TE 260 +66
195 Wan'Dale Robinson NYG - WR 208 +13
196 Gardner Minshew II LV - QB 275 +79
198 Ben Sinnott WAS - TE 225 +27
199 Ja'Lynn Polk NE - WR 229 +30
201 Alexander Mattison LV - RB 230 +29
202 Ja'Tavion Sanders CAR - TE 258 +56
203 Brenden Rice LAC - WR 301 +98
205 Tyler Boyd FA - WR 276 +71
206 Malachi Corley NYJ - WR 285 +79
208 Kadarius Toney KC - WR 242 +34
212 Will Shipley PHI - RB 272 +60
213 Dalvin Cook FA - RB 288 +75
214 Demarcus Robinson LAR - WR 247 +33
218 Zay Jones ARI - WR 379 +161
219 Samaje Perine DEN - RB 283 +64
220 Tank Bigsby JAC - RB 264 +44
224 Mike Gesicki CIN - TE 273 +49
230 Michael Penix Jr. ATL - QB 284 +54
232 Noah Fant SEA - TE 255 +23
234 Aidan O'Connell LV - QB 320 +86
240 Indianapolis Colts IND - DST 278 +38
248 Javon Baker NE - WR 302 +54
253 Detroit Lions DET - DST 355 +102
254 Greg Dulcich DEN - TE 282 +28
255 Luke McCaffrey WAS - WR 330 +75
260 Jacksonville Jaguars JAC - DST 279 +19
269 Sam Howell SEA - QB 397 +128
270 Israel Abanikanda NYJ - RB 309 +39
275 Colby Parkinson LAR - TE 389 +114
276 Erick All Jr. CIN - TE 294 +18
278 Dylan Laube LV - RB 364 +86
279 Joe Flacco IND - QB 387 +108
280 Eric Gray NYG - RB 327 +47
282 Michael Carter ARI - RB 331 +49
286 Drew Lock NYG - QB 367 +81
291 Rasheen Ali BAL - RB 392 +101
292 Jameis Winston CLE - QB 347 +55
299 Hayden Hurst LAC - TE 353 +54
300 Jalen Tolbert DAL - WR 373 +73
302 Donald Parham Jr. LAC - TE 381 +79
305 Jake Browning CIN - QB 338 +33
306 Jerick McKinnon FA - RB 322 +16
313 Jauan Jennings SF - WR 384 +71