Skip to main content

Dissenting Opinions: Football Rankings - 2024 Draft

Craig Phillips (FF Prophet) vs Expert Consensus (All Experts)

Craig Phillips likes him more


Rank Player ECR Diff.
6 Sam LaPorta DET - TE 23 +17
28 Isiah Pacheco KC - RB 40 +12
31 De'Von Achane MIA - RB 44 +13
39 Rashee Rice KC - WR 63 +24
41 Kenneth Walker III SEA - RB 55 +14
45 Tank Dell HOU - WR 59 +14
54 Rhamondre Stevenson NE - RB 66 +12
58 James Conner ARI - RB 70 +12
60 Jayden Reed GB - WR 76 +16
63 Jaxon Smith-Njigba SEA - WR 87 +24
64 Justin Fields PIT - QB 239 +175
66 Tony Pollard TEN - RB 78 +12
68 Javonte Williams DEN - RB 82 +14
71 David Njoku CLE - TE 89 +18
72 Austin Ekeler WAS - RB 104 +32
73 Tyler Lockett SEA - WR 105 +32
75 Christian Watson GB - WR 109 +34
78 Tyjae Spears TEN - RB 93 +15
79 Courtland Sutton DEN - WR 97 +18
83 Mike Williams NYJ - WR 115 +32
87 Adam Thielen CAR - WR 140 +53
89 Josh Downs IND - WR 124 +35
90 Jakobi Meyers LV - WR 113 +23
91 Gabe Davis JAC - WR 144 +53
94 Jahan Dotson WAS - WR 135 +41
99 Chuba Hubbard CAR - RB 131 +32
100 Roschon Johnson CHI - RB 148 +48
103 Romeo Doubs GB - WR 129 +26
104 Jameson Williams DET - WR 127 +23
107 Elijah Moore CLE - WR 169 +62
108 Khalil Herbert CHI - RB 149 +41
109 Brandin Cooks DAL - WR 136 +27
110 Jerry Jeudy CLE - WR 137 +27
114 Jerome Ford CLE - RB 130 +16
117 Curtis Samuel BUF - WR 134 +17
118 Antonio Gibson NE - RB 132 +14
119 Rashid Shaheed NO - WR 150 +31
120 Wan'Dale Robinson NYG - WR 167 +47
122 Joshua Palmer LAC - WR 146 +24
123 Quentin Johnston LAC - WR 161 +38
125 Marvin Mims Jr. DEN - WR 174 +49
128 Kendre Miller NO - RB 151 +23
131 Michael Wilson ARI - WR 168 +37
134 Tyler Boyd FA - WR 236 +102
135 AJ Dillon GB - RB 185 +50
136 Rashod Bateman BAL - WR 178 +42
138 Darren Waller NYG - TE 245 +107
140 Odell Beckham Jr. MIA - WR 254 +114
141 Tyler Allgeier ATL - RB 153 +12
143 Darius Slayton NYG - WR 213 +70
144 Jalin Hyatt NYG - WR 202 +58
145 Jonathan Mingo CAR - WR 219 +74
149 J.K. Dobbins LAC - RB 171 +22
151 Zay Jones ARI - WR 230 +79
152 Tucker Kraft GB - TE 170 +18
153 Michael Mayer LV - TE 212 +59
154 Darnell Mooney ATL - WR 184 +30
155 Miles Sanders CAR - RB 183 +28
156 Treylon Burks TEN - WR 218 +62
160 Dameon Pierce HOU - RB 198 +38
161 Michael Thomas FA - WR 263 +102
166 Cedric Tillman CLE - WR 267 +101
168 Alexander Mattison LV - RB 206 +38
174 K.J. Osborn NE - WR 256 +82
175 Michael Gallup LV - WR 276 +101
176 Brandon Aubrey DAL - K 190 +14
177 Kenneth Gainwell PHI - RB 208 +31
181 Jamaal Williams NO - RB 234 +53
182 Gerald Everett CHI - TE 238 +56
185 Kadarius Toney KC - WR 287 +102
186 Alec Pierce IND - WR 255 +69
188 DJ Chark Jr. LAC - WR 264 +76
191 Jake Elliott PHI - K 203 +12
195 Rondale Moore ATL - WR 248 +53
196 DeVante Parker PHI - WR 284 +88
199 Michael Carter ARI - RB 280 +81
202 Kenny Pickett PHI - QB 344 +142
203 Kendrick Bourne NE - WR 232 +29
205 Robert Woods HOU - WR 301 +96
206 John Metchie III HOU - WR 335 +129
208 Hunter Renfrow FA - WR 321 +113
210 Josh Reynolds DEN - WR 275 +65
211 Denver Broncos DEN - DST 252 +41
214 Demarcus Robinson LAR - WR 228 +14
216 Andrei Iosivas CIN - WR 272 +56
217 Justice Hill BAL - RB 247 +30
219 New England Patriots NE - DST 290 +71
223 Tyler Scott CHI - WR 302 +79
226 Marquez Valdes-Scantling BUF - WR 330 +104
227 Jerick McKinnon FA - RB 285 +58
229 Tutu Atwell LAR - WR 331 +102
231 Allen Lazard NYJ - WR 336 +105
232 Tyler Higbee LAR - TE 250 +18
237 Jeff Wilson Jr. MIA - RB 279 +42
238 Samaje Perine DEN - RB 258 +20
240 Trey Palmer TB - WR 270 +30
242 A.T. Perry NO - WR 274 +32
243 JuJu Smith-Schuster NE - WR 337 +94
244 Noah Brown HOU - WR 294 +50
247 Skyy Moore KC - WR 346 +99
248 Indianapolis Colts IND - DST 260 +12
250 Las Vegas Raiders LV - DST 327 +77
253 Blake Grupe NO - K 286 +33
256 Israel Abanikanda NYJ - RB 292 +36
257 Kareem Hunt FA - RB 289 +32
259 Evan Hull IND - RB 293 +34
261 Xavier Hutchinson HOU - WR 376 +115
262 Donovan Peoples-Jones DET - WR 351 +89
264 Dalvin Cook FA - RB 299 +35
265 Emeka Egbuka FA - WR 415 +150
266 Detroit Lions DET - DST 295 +29
272 Emari Demercado ARI - RB 306 +34
274 Deuce Vaughn DAL - RB 288 +14
276 Wil Lutz DEN - K 329 +53
277 Pierre Strong Jr. CLE - RB 298 +21
278 Los Angeles Rams LAR - DST 348 +70
280 Jordan Mason SF - RB 296 +16
282 Logan Thomas FA - TE 320 +38
283 Joshua Kelley FA - RB 318 +35
284 Sam Howell SEA - QB 347 +63
287 D'Ernest Johnson JAC - RB 304 +17
288 Brandon McManus WAS - K 333 +45
291 Greg Zuerlein NYJ - K 326 +35
293 Ronnie Rivers LAR - RB 313 +20
295 Chris Boswell PIT - K 355 +60
296 Greg Joseph GB - K 359 +63
297 Green Bay Packers GB - DST 324 +27
299 Carolina Panthers CAR - DST 350 +51
300 Michael Badgley DET - K 378 +78
302 Cam Akers MIN - RB 315 +13
304 Cordarrelle Patterson PIT - RB 316 +12
306 Atlanta Falcons ATL - DST 371 +65
311 Eddy Pineiro CAR - K 379 +68
316 Chase McLaughlin TB - K 367 +51
317 Mac Jones JAC - QB 423 +106
319 Latavius Murray FA - RB 334 +15
321 Anders Carlson GB - K 394 +73
322 Brett Maher FA - K 453 +131
323 Seattle Seahawks SEA - DST 369 +46
324 Graham Gano NYG - K 365 +41
325 Tampa Bay Buccaneers TB - DST 345 +20
327 Donovan Edwards FA - RB 398 +71
328 Keaontay Ingram KC - RB 343 +15
330 Craig Reynolds DET - RB 356 +26
332 Leonard Fournette FA - RB 417 +85
333 TreVeyon Henderson FA - RB 477 +144
334 Royce Freeman DAL - RB 353 +19

Expert Consensus likes him more


Rank Player Expert Diff.
17 Marvin Harrison Jr. ARI - WR 212 +195
22 Drake London ATL - WR 48 +26
42 Derrick Henry BAL - RB 81 +39
49 Trey McBride ARI - TE 62 +13
52 Anthony Richardson IND - QB 84 +32
53 Malik Nabers NYG - WR 220 +167
64 Kyler Murray ARI - QB 102 +38
65 Dalton Kincaid BUF - TE 106 +41
68 Jordan Love GB - QB 105 +37
72 D'Andre Swift CHI - RB 86 +14
73 Zamir White LV - RB 96 +23
75 Brock Purdy SF - QB 101 +26
86 Tua Tagovailoa MIA - QB 112 +26
88 Kyle Pitts ATL - TE 137 +49
90 Rome Odunze CHI - WR 222 +132
92 Jared Goff DET - QB 126 +34
95 Caleb Williams CHI - QB 241 +146
98 Jake Ferguson DAL - TE 132 +34
101 Kirk Cousins ATL - QB 130 +29
103 Trevor Lawrence JAC - QB 116 +13
108 Jayden Daniels WAS - QB 275 +167
110 Brock Bowers LV - TE 273 +163
111 Matthew Stafford LAR - QB 127 +16
112 Zack Moss CIN - RB 124 +12
114 Dalton Schultz HOU - TE 179 +65
116 Aaron Rodgers NYJ - QB 148 +32
117 Cole Kmet CHI - TE 133 +16
118 Chase Brown CIN - RB 147 +29
119 Ladd McConkey LAC - WR 270 +151
122 Pat Freiermuth PIT - TE 142 +20
125 Keon Coleman BUF - WR 263 +138
126 Baker Mayfield TB - QB 162 +36
128 Deshaun Watson CLE - QB 146 +18
133 Geno Smith SEA - QB 150 +17
138 Trey Benson ARI - RB 336 +198
139 Luke Musgrave GB - TE 164 +25
141 Brian Thomas Jr. JAC - WR 268 +127
142 Jonathon Brooks CAR - RB 308 +166
143 Blake Corum LAR - RB 314 +171
147 Will Levis TEN - QB 197 +50
154 Derek Carr NO - QB 170 +16
155 Cade Otton TB - TE 236 +81
156 Hunter Henry NE - TE 209 +53
157 Rico Dowdle DAL - RB 198 +41
166 Adonai Mitchell IND - WR 286 +120
172 Dallas Cowboys DAL - DST 187 +15
175 New York Jets NYJ - DST 192 +17
176 Cleveland Browns CLE - DST 190 +14
181 Dontayvion Wicks GB - WR 194 +13
187 Kansas City Chiefs KC - DST 207 +20
188 Xavier Legette CAR - WR 285 +97
191 Harrison Butker KC - K 204 +13
195 Troy Franklin DEN - WR 271 +76
197 Pittsburgh Steelers PIT - DST 225 +28
205 Tyler Conklin NYJ - TE 255 +50
209 Drake Maye NE - QB 254 +45
211 Younghoe Koo ATL - K 224 +13
215 Noah Fant SEA - TE 267 +52
221 Isaiah Likely BAL - TE 246 +25
222 Evan McPherson CIN - K 239 +17
224 Ray Davis BUF - RB 335 +111
227 Taysom Hill NO - TE 258 +31
244 Braelon Allen NYJ - RB 326 +82
249 Audric Estime DEN - RB 331 +82
251 Mike Gesicki CIN - TE 290 +39
257 Devontez Walker BAL - WR 269 +12
265 Jacksonville Jaguars JAC - DST 310 +45
266 Will Shipley PHI - RB 329 +63
269 Daniel Carlson LV - K 281 +12
271 Jelani Woods IND - TE 298 +27
273 Tank Bigsby JAC - RB 305 +32
291 Michael Penix Jr. ATL - QB 307 +16